Summary
For years, I used controllers with naked analog sticks. But after I dressed up my first pair of thumbsticks with some removable thumbstick covers, I never looked back. Here’s why.
Thumbstick Grips Prevent Joystick Rubber Degradation
I got my first wireless controller in 2013. It wasn’t a high-end model, but I remember it was touted as a pretty solid budget option. Less than a year later, in early 2014, I remember playingSouth Park: The Stick of Truthwith the left thumbstick completely naked, its plastic skeleton exposed because the rubber coating had completely worn away.
In 2015, I got an Xbox One controller, which was a marked improvement in all areas compared to the previous one. Its thumbstick rubber lasted more than two years before disintegrating. This time, I ordered replacement sticks, but those, too, wore down over time. I still have that pair of thumbsticks lying around, so you can see the extent of the degradation below.
By then, I had heard about thumbstick covers and decided to slip them on said controller. The result was phenomenal. I used the controller until mid-2022 before it died, with the sticks staying the same as they were the moment I put the thumbstick covers on. There was no further rubber degradation after almost half a decade of heavy use.
Impressed by the results on my Xbox controller, I equipped myNintendo Switch Litewith thumbstick covers on day one. As you’re able to see below, its analog sticks still look pristine even though I’ve enjoyed the tiny console for hundreds, if not a thousand-plus hours. I did the same with my two PS4 controllers, and those, too, looked pristine when I sold the console in 2021.
If you’re not someone who likes to collect controllers and instead only use one or two gamepads, thumbstick covers will prevent thumbstick rubber degradation many controllers suffer from. But that’s not the only thing they’re good at.
Covers Massively Improve Thumbstick Grip
Personally, I find Xbox controllers to have the grippiest analog sticks on the market. But even those sticks get grippier when you wrap them up with a quality pair of covers.
The improvement in grip is far more substantial on other controllers. I made the mistake of not having a pair of covers ready and waiting when mySteam Deckarrived, so I had to retrofit the Switch Lite covers on its thumbsticks on the first day because Steam Deck’s analogs are slippy as heck (I’m talking specifically about the original LCD Steam Deck here).
While the Steam Deck’s concave thumbsticks are an outlier because they’re touch-sensitive and used to trigger gyro aiming, I’ve noticed that controllers with convex sticks—8BitDo Ultimate,DualSense, andJoycons, for example—benefit more than controllers featuring concave thumbsticks.
That said, if you do end up getting a nice pair of thumbstick covers, they can make every pair of sticks, be they concave or convex, grippier.
Before I move on, I should also mention that many people online claim that tall grips, like the ones below, improve their aiming. Personally, I didn’t find a difference, butyour mileage may vary.
They’re Cheap and You Can Buy Them Anywhere
If thumbstick covers were a pricey accessory, you might read this and think, “Well, I won’t spend a good chunk of cash just to end up disappointed,” but you can buy a pair of thumbstick grips for as little as a few bucks.
Personally, I useSkull & Co. thumbstick gripsbecause they’re by far the grippiest ones I’ve tried, and because they come in a variety of colors. you’re able to find them on Amazon, and while they command a small premium over most other covers, they’re well worth the price.
Just remember that you should use convex grips for convex sticks and vice versa because doing otherwise will make the covers fall off rather easily (this happened to me when I put concave grips on my 8BitDo Ultimate’s convex sticks).
